|
Ask Our Lawyer
by Rod Taylor
Q: A couple of months ago you
wrote about the definition of the word biker in a dictionary.
What ever happened to that?
A: I though I would keep you
posted on the progress of that. With the help of ABATE staff and
interested members, we sent the following letter to the dictionary
publisher. We havent heard from them yet, but Ill let
you know as soon as we get a response.
Karen Wilkinson
MERRIAM -WEBSTER, INC.
47 Federal Street
P.O. Box 281
Springfield, Massachusetts 01102
Dear Ms. Wilkinson:
Thank you for your prompt and courteous
response to our question regarding the definition of the word biker
in your unabridged on-line dictionary and presumably in the New
Third International Dictionary bound volume. We would like to take
this opportunity to propose some revisions to the definition appearing
in your publications and suggest possible alternatives.
The law firm of which we are members
currently represents several motorcycle safety organizations. As
you may be aware, the motorcycling community tends to be self-organized
and members of a number of different motorcycling related organizations.
These include the regional, local and state chapters of the ABATE
organization (ABATE stands for American Bikers Aimed Toward Education),
as well as the national Motorcycle Riders Foundation. Our office
is affiliated with a number of these organizations, and is also
involved with the national American Motorcycle Association. We have
recently become aware that the usage listed in your publications
for bikers can be seen by motorcyclists and the non-motorcycling
public as a derogatory stereotyping of those of us who ride motorcycles.
While we realize from the content of your recent email that the
marker especially tends to indicate that not all motorcyclists
would be members of organized gangs, we believe that its inclusion
as the sole definition of biker certainly would lead
most casual readers of your publications to that conclusion.
While no one would dispute that there
are criminal elements or gang members who do ride motorcycles, they
are by far the smallest minority of motorcycle riders. Most motorcycle
riders are courteous and safe individuals. They may be local professionals,
including doctors, lawyers, accountants, architects and small business
owners. While some people who ride motorcycles indulge in a motorcycling
centered lifestyle, others ride them simply for recreational purposes.
To group all motorcyclists with the small percentage who might be
members of organized gangs does a disservice to motorcyclists at
large. We would suggest that the same definition applied to any
other subgroup of the American public would be considered insulting
if not derogatory.
We are therefore asking that your organization undertake to modify
its listing of biker in your publications. We have included
with this letter an article written for publication in several state
motorcycle newsletters discussing this issue and noting different
definitions of the word biker. We would suggest that
perhaps the Cambridge International Dictionary of American English
definition would be more appropriate as a primary definition of
the word biker. That definition is, as noted in the
attached document, someone who rides a motorcycle or bicycle.
While we would certainly understand your organizations desire
to include some description of the usage of biker as
referring to those who are involved in an organized gang, we believe
that it should not be the primary definition for biker.
Perhaps a sub-usage that indicates the term is sometimes used to
describe those members of an organized gang would be sufficient
to address that issue while not making a broader stereotype.
We thank you for your attention to
this matter and would respectfully request that you address it and
respond to us at your convenience. Members of the motorcycling community
would appreciate your attention to this matter and we look forward
to hearing from you.
Very truly yours,
Rodney V. Taylor
If you have any questions you would like to ask the lawyer, please
submit them to: ASK OUR LAWYER, P.O. Box 2850, Indianapolis, Indiana
46206-2850.
|